Nexia TS Managing Director, Henry Tan’s Media Interview with Finance Monthly
With China’s economic development and growth over the last 20 years, more and more foreign companies have been expanding their businesses into China, either through direct investment or through increasing numbers of cross-border transactions. However, doing business in China has distinctive challenges that must be considered, not only because of the potential language barriers, but also because of various business-related regulations and tax requirements that are unique to the country.
Our consultants at Nexia TS (Shanghai) Ltd provide business and tax advisory services to global clients investing in and/or doing business in China. Our service offerings range from planning, structuring and the setting up of foreign-invested businesses, as well as a focus on tax consulting and advisory for all aspects of Chinese taxation. Chinese company and employment law advisory services are also offered. We are able to provide compliance work that caters to assurance and other statutory needs.
Since we established our practice in China in 2001, we have assisted many international companies with their inbound investments into China, setting up direct presence and fulfilling the domestic regulations. Overall, we find that our experience and expertise with the Chinese regulations and business environment have also benefitted our clients.
In our experience, we have found that the simplest structures are often the best. It is potentially useful for foreign parent companies to own their Chinese subsidiaries through offshore holding companies in low tax jurisdictions that also had favorable tax treaties in place with China. In many cases, multinational groups use layers of holding companies in their structures. Related party transactions between sister companies and the ultimate parent company were essentially designed to extract profits out of Chinese operations without being taxed. Things have changed since 2008 though, and China has implemented many new regulations intended to ensure that the country receives its fair share of taxes. Where a foreign company sets up and registers a subsidiary in China, it is now usually most tax efficient when the subsidiary autonomously performs its business functions. The more control the China subsidiary has over its operations, the better – especially with respect to participation in the VAT system. Furthermore, more autonomy from the parent company generally results in fewer issues with respect to expense deductibility for corporate income taxes. It is true that profits dividends paid to the subsidiary shareholders are taxed at 10%, or less in some cases, but there is tax savings over attempting to extract profits through royalties or cross-border services that are subject to both withholding tax and VAT. Foreign companies operating in China nowadays must take these issues under consideration.
For foreign companies operating in China without setting up a registered entity, there are also tax-related considerations. It is important to properly structure these transactions. For those that simply sell goods into China, the buyer of the goods handles all of the China-related issues. However, for those that sell services, or a combination of goods and services, into China, it is crucial to minimize the risks associated with being recognized as permanent establishment for corporate income tax purposes, and also to ensure that tax treaty benefits are applied to and recognized by the respective tax authorities. Likewise, VAT now applies to all cross-border service transactions, so proper structuring of the service agreements is essential.
Many foreign investors assume that setting up an entity in China that relies heavily on related party transactions may be very simple when using special purpose entities. For example, a US company might set up a holding company in Hong Kong, to take advantage of lower withholding tax rates on royalties obtained by selling IP usage rights to its China subsidiary. However, China has closed many loopholes with tax officials scrutinising royalty and other similar agreements. If certain criterias are not met, the royalty payments may not be deductible for the China subsidiary.
Another area often overlooked is how China’s tax rules have changed with respect to the indirect equity transfer of Chinese entities by offshore parties. Considerable paperwork must now be filed in China during such transactions, even if no tax will be assessed on the transfer. Penalties can be quite severe if the offshore transferer and transferee do not comply with the documentation filing requirements.
Since the introduction of the Corporate Income Tax Law in 2008, China’s State Administration of Taxation has implemented many new General Tax Anti-Avoidance Rules that allow the country to pursue foreign companies doing business in China and purposefully setting up the businesses or transactions to avoid Chinese taxation. With the advent of BEPS and increasing global cooperation between countries, it has become much easier for China to pursue such cases.
Companies within certain specific industries can enjoy corporate income tax breaks, and these industries are normally associated with high-tech manufacturing and R&D. In addition, Chinese local municipal governments attempt to attract foreign investments by offering tax exemption or tax rebates on the portions of VAT or corporate income taxes to which they are entitled. There are also incentives for companies investung in energy-saving and environmental protection facilities, which they can deduct a certain amount of their investments for corporate income tax purposes.
How can multinational companies move finances in an efficient way between their international offices?
Foreign companies with regional headquarters in China’s free trade zones have a few options for moving funds between China and other countries. However, China generally has strict foreign exchange rules in place that limit the movement of funds via profit dividends, loans, or other genuine transactions between the parties. Capital usually cannot be moved out of the country without closing and liquidating the business in China. Companies should plan exit strategies at the time of business setup. However, regulations are always subject to change, so such strategies should be analyzed continuously and updated as needed.
Unveiled in October 2013, the One Belt One Road initiative is a development framework aimed at enhancing trade and investment connections between Central and Eastern European countries and Asian countries. It not only plays a role as an important economic link between countries, that also helps to relieve some of the issues that were caused by China’s economic development during recent years, such as overcapacity, falling demand for commodities like steel, investment bubbles, lower rates of return on investment and so forth. The key to success of this initiative also depends on joint participation from other countries to bring in high technology to increase the rate of return on investments, instead of just building roads and bridges and ports, which are the key strengths of China in leading this initiative. The collaborative stance that China places on this initiative is very helpful. For example, it acts like entrepreneurs who would like to set up business with existing infrastructures and available financing.
According to the futures prices on steel and copper traded on the Shanghai Futures Exchange, the dominant Futures prices on steel and copper have been rising since 2016, which means that demand for domestic commodities has been gradually recovering. With more deals and projects announced in the future, we foresee that the demand for domestic commodities will continue to rise further.
This initiative in the long run will benefit the global economy as a whole, and help rebuild economic interactions between countries that were in existence before the 2008 economic crisis. It not only increases the routes by which transported goods can reach destination countries around Asia and Europe, but also revitalizes the economies and unlocks potential demand from the One Belt One Road countries.
For more information, please contact:
Managing Director, Nexia TS
Director of Global Expansion & Tax Advisory (China),
Nexia TS Shanghai